Prior to joining WWE, Farrelly was a two-time International Heavyweight Champion during his tenure in Irish Whip Wrestling. He has held the WWE Championship on two occasions, the World Heavyweight Championship once, and the WWE United States Championship twice, as well as winning the 2010 King of the Ring tournament and the 2012 Royal Rumble match.
- Florida Championship Wrestling Heavyweight Championship
- Irish Whip Wrestling International Heavyweight Championship
- WWE World Heavyweight Championship / WWE Championship
- WWE United States Championship