Before signing with WWE, Arias wrestled under the ring name Incognito under which he had worked for professional wrestling promotions such as Asistencia Asesoría y Administración (AAA) in Mexico and Chikara in the United States. He is the second wrestler to use the name Sin Cara in WWE as the first was Mexican born star Místico (Luis Urive).
- Florida Championship Wrestling Florida Tag Team Championship
- Nevermore Championship Wrestling Light Heavyweight Championship
- World Wrestling Association Middleweight Championship
- WWE NXT Tag Team Championship