In 2007, Colón signed a developmental contract with WWE, being assigned to Florida Championship Wrestling. In this promotion he was teamed with Eric Perez, forming a tag team known as The Puerto Rican Nightmares. On February 23, 2008, they became the first wrestlers to hold the FCW Florida Tag Team Championship. Upon being promoted to the main brand, he was teamed with his brother. Subsequently, The Colóns became the first team to hold the WWE Tag Team Championship and World Tag Team Championship at the same time, making them the first Unified WWE Tag Team Champions.
- Florida Championship Wrestling Tag Team Championship
- Funking Conservatory Tag Team Championship
- World Wrestling Council Puerto Rico Heavyweight Championship
- World Wrestling Council Universal Heavyweight Championship
- World Wrestling Council World Junior Heavyweight Championship
- World Wrestling Council World Tag Team Championship
- WWE World Tag Team Championship